The Evolution of Metalcore: A Historical Journey and the Top 13 Bands of the Ever Evolving, Pulverizing Genre
Metalcore is a subgenre of heavy metal that combines elements of extreme metal and hardcore punk. It typically features the aggressive guitar riffs, double-bass drumming, and harsh vocals associated with metal, along with breakdowns and other characteristics rooted in hardcore punk. It often incorporates melodic elements, varying tempos, and dynamic song structures as well.
It’s a genre that came crashing together at the intersection of heavy metal and hardcore punk, yet continues to evolve into a powerhouse within the heavy music scene. With roots deeply embedded in the rebellious spirit of punk and the aggressive tones of metal, Metalcore has undergone a fascinating journey from its humble beginnings to becoming a driving force in the diverse landscape of heavy music. In this comprehensive exploration, we’ll delve into the genre’s origins, trace its evolution, examine its impact on the broader heavy metal genre and count down the top 13 Metalcore bands who have defined the genre as a whole.
Roots and Beginnings
The roots of the genre can be traced back to the mid-1980s, when hardcore punk and heavy metal began to intertwine in the underground music scene. Bands like AGNOSTIC FRONT and D.R.I. were already blending elements of punk and metal, laying the groundwork for what would later be recognized as Metalcore. However, it wasn’t until the 1990s that this new type of aggressive music really began to take shape.
One of the pioneering bands in this fusion was a group called EARTH CRISIS, whose 1995 album “Destroy the Machines” is often regarded as a landmark release in the development of the genre. Characterized by chugging guitar riffs, breakdowns, and intense vocal delivery, EARTH CRISIS set a precedent for the aggression and emotional intensity that would come to define the sound.
Standout Bands and Influences
As Metalcore gained momentum, several bands emerged as flagbearers for the genre. Among them, KILLSWITCH ENGAGE is often credited with bringing metalcore into the mainstream with their breakthrough album “The End of Heartache” in 2004. The band’s ability to seamlessly blend melodic elements with crushing heaviness set a new standard for the genre.
Another influential band in the early 2000s was ATREYU, whose energetic mix of metal and hardcore elements showcased the genre’s dynamic potential. BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE, with their 2005 album “The Poison,” brought a melodic sensibility to the genre, further diversifying its sonic palette.
CONVERGE, a band formed in the early ’90s, is often hailed as a cornerstone of the genre. Their intricate musicianship, complex song structures, and raw intensity have influenced countless metal and hardcore bands. THE DILLINGER ESCAPE PLAN, with their avant-garde approach, challenged traditional boundaries and added a layer of experimentation to the genre.
Evolution
As Metalcore entered the 21st century, the sound continued to evolve, incorporating elements from various subgenres within heavy music. Bands like ARCHITECTS and PARKWAY DRIVE brought a more polished and atmospheric sound to the genre, expanding its sonic horizons.
The introduction of electronic elements became a defining feature in the subgenre known as Electronicore. Bands like ENTER SHAKIRI, with their fusion of post-hardcore, metal, and electronic music, exemplified this trend. The use of synthesizers and programmed elements added an all new ethereal dimension to the genre’s sonic landscape.
In the mid-2010s, a wave of bands embraced a more emotional and introspective approach, giving rise to what is often labeled as “Melodic Metalcore.” ARCHITECTS‘ “All Our Gods Have Abandoned Us” (2016) and AUGUST BURNS RED‘s “Found in Far Away Places” (2015) exemplify this shift, incorporating complex melodies and exploring lyrical themes with depth and vulnerability.
The incorporation of progressive elements also became prominent in bands like BETWEEN THE BURIED and PERIPHERY. These acts pushed the boundaries of the then burgeoning era, infusing it with intricate instrumentation and progressive song structures.
Modern Metalcore Scene
Today, the scene is more diverse and expansive than ever. While some bands stay true to the genre’s roots with unrelenting aggression and breakdowns, others experiment with a myriad of influences, blurring the lines between Metalcore and adjacent subgenres.
ARCHITECTS, with their socially conscious lyrics and dynamic sound, continue to be at the forefront of the genre. BRING ME THE HORIZON, initially rooted in the standard breakdowns, brutal delivery and keyboard nuances, has transitioned into a more alternative and electronic sounding band, openly showcasing the genre’s ever evolving adaptability.
ERRA, with their fusion of Djent and progressive, and CODE ORANGE, known for their hardcore-infused approach, represent the genre’s constant evolution. Bands like CURRENTS and FIT FOR A KING bring a modern heaviness, combining brutal breakdowns with melodic hooks.
This particular genre’s journey from its roots in the underground punk and metal scenes to its current status as a diverse and influential division of heavy music reflects its ability to adapt and innovate. The fusion of aggression, melody, and experimentation has allowed Metalcore to resonate with a broad audience while maintaining its core identity. As the genre continues to evolve, one can only anticipate the exciting directions that it will take in the years to come, further solidifying its place in the rich tapestry of aggressive, heavy music.
Each of the following bands has played a pivotal role in shaping Metalcore‘s landscape, contributing to it’s diversity and influencing countless bands that followed in their footsteps. We now give you…
The Top 13 Metalcore Bands That Define The Genre
13 – UNDEROATH
UNDEROATH, hailing from Tampa, Florida, emerged as a pioneering force in the scene, contributing significantly to the genre’s evolution.
Formed in 1997, the band initially showcased a more straightforward blend of metal and post-hardcore on early releases like “Act of Depression” (1999) and “Cries of the Past” (2000). However, it was with their breakthrough album “They’re Only Chasing Safety” (2004) that UNDEROATH achieved widespread recognition.
The incorporation of melodic elements, clean singing by Spencer Chamberlain, and the dynamic interplay between harsh and clean vocals marked a departure from traditional Metalcore conventions. This evolution continued with subsequent releases, including “Define the Great Line” (2006) and “Lost in the Sound of Separation” (2008), solidifying UNDEROATH‘s influence on the burgeoning genre.
UNDEROATH‘s impact lies in their ability to push boundaries and challenge the genre’s sonic constraints. By embracing a more melodic and experimental approach, they paved the way for a new wave of bands to explore diverse sounds and incorporate clean vocals without sacrificing intensity.
UNDEROATH‘s innovative spirit and willingness to evolve over their career have left an enduring mark on Metalcore, inspiring bands to experiment with the genre’s boundaries and contributing to its continued growth and diversity.
12 – THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA
THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA, originating from Dayton, Ohio, has been a prominent and influential figure in the genre since their formation in 2005.
Taking their name from the well-known novel of the same name, the band has become known for their intricate compositions, relentless breakdowns and their distinctive combination of aggressive and melodic elements. The group quickly rose to prominence and increasing awareness with releases like “Dear Love: A Beautiful Discord” (2006) and “Plagues” (2007).
THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA‘s incorporation of atmospheric elements, ambient textures, and thought-provoking lyrical themes showcased a level of sophistication that set them apart in the Metalcore landscape. Albums like “With Roots Above and Branches Below” (2009) and “Dead Throne” (2011) drove their presence home, influencing the trajectory of the genre.
THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA‘s influence is notable for their commitment to experimentation. Their willingness to incorporate electronic elements, clean vocals, and thematic depth into their sound paved the way for a more diverse and expansive landscape. The band’s dynamic evolution and ability to blend aggression with melody have inspired a generation of heavy music acts to explore new sonic territories, ensuring THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA‘s lasting impact on the genre’s creative landscape.
11 – EVERY TIME I DIE
EVERY TIME I DIE was a renowned American Metalcore band known for their unique blend of hardcore punk, Southern rock, and metal influences. Formed in 1998 in Buffalo, New York, the band consisted of members Keith Buckley (vocals), Andy Williams (guitar), Jordan Buckley (guitar), Stephen Micciche (bass), and Clayton “Goose” Holyoak (drums).
The band’s significance to the Metalcore genre was in their ability to seamlessly fuse various musical elements, creating a sound that is both aggressive and melodic. Their live performances and powerful lyrics garnered them a dedicated fanbase and critical acclaim within the metal community.
Their breakthrough album, “Ex Lives” (2012), received widespread acclaim for its raw intensity and emotional depth. Tracks like “Underwater Bimbos from Outer Space” and “Revival Mode” demonstrated the band’s ability to push audio boundaries while staying true to their roots.
With a discography that spanned over two decades, EVERY TIME I DIE exemplified Metalcore, inspiring countless other acts and leaving a massive dent on the heavy music landscape. Despite breaking up in 2022, the band’s innovation and authenticity ensured that they still remain a revered force in the history of metal.
10 – AUGUST BURNS RED
AUGUST BURNS RED is a prominent American metal band hailing from Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Formed in 2003, the band consists of members Jake Luhrs (vocals), JB Brubaker (lead guitar), Brent Rambler (rhythm guitar), Dustin Davidson (bass), and Matt Greiner (drums). Known for their intricate guitar work, dynamic rhythms, and intense live performances, AUGUST BURNS RED has solidified its place as one of the leading acts in the Metalcore genre.
The band gained widespread recognition with their debut album “Thrill Seeker” in 2005, showcasing their technical proficiency and relentless energy. Their sophomore release, “Messengers” (2007), further propelled them into the heavy music spotlight, gaining the band a feverishly growing fanbase.
AUGUST BURNS RED continued to evolve their sound with albums like “Constellations” (2009), “Leveler” (2011), and “Rescue & Restore” (2013), incorporating elements of progressive metal and melodic hardcore while staying true to their roots.
With a discography spanning over two decades, AUGUST BURNS RED continues to push boundaries and inspire audiences worldwide with their powerful music and unwavering dedication to their blistering, yet beautiful, art.
9 – ALL THAT REMAINS
ALL THAT REMAINS is a prominent American metal band hailing from Springfield, Massachusetts. Formed in 1998, the band initially started as a melodic death metal outfit before transitioning into strait-up Metalcore. The band’s lineup has seen several changes over the years, but its core members include vocalist Philip Labonte and rhythm guitarist Mike Martin. (Special mention must be made to late-guitarist Oli Herbert who we tragically lost in 2018)
The band gained significant attention with their breakthrough album, “The Fall of Ideals” (2006), which featured hit singles like “This Calling” and “The Air That I Breathe.” The album showcased their signature blend of melodic hooks, aggressive riffing, and Labonte‘s versatile vocal delivery, earning them widespread acclaim within the metal community.
Following the success of “The Fall of Ideals,” ALL THAT REMAINS continued to solidify their presence in the scene with albums like “Overcome” (2008) and “For We Are Many” (2010). These releases further demonstrated their ability to craft anthemic tracks while exploring themes of perseverance and resilience.
Over the years, ALL THAT REMAINS has continued to evolve their sound, incorporating elements of hard rock and alternative metal into their music. Despite facing challenges and criticisms from some fans for their stylistic changes, the band has remained resilient and true to their artistic vision.
ALL THAT REMAINS are still a significant force within the Metalcore genre, with a resilience that speaks deafening volumes.
8 – ARCHITECTS
ARCHITECTS is a British Metalcore band that has carved a formidable presence within the genre since their formation in 2004 in Brighton, England. Comprising members Sam Carter (vocals), Dan Searle (drums), Alex Dean (bass) and Adam Christianson (guitar), ARCHITECTS has consistently crushed the boundaries of what has become known as modern-day Metalcore.
Within the genre, ARCHITECTS stand out for their seamless blend of pummeling riffs, intricate melodies, and dynamic song structures. They’re known for their technical proficiency and their ability to seamlessly incorporate elements from various sub-genres of metal, ranging from progressive and mathcore to post-metal influences.
Lyrically, ARCHITECTS tackle weighty subjects such as environmental destruction, societal issues, and existential themes with a poignant and introspective approach. Their thought-provoking lyrics often reflect a deep sense of social and environmental consciousness, making them stand out as a band with a message beyond the music.
ARCHITECTS‘ influence within the genre is undeniable. They’ve inspired countless bands with their innovative approach to songwriting, technical prowess, and socially conscious lyrics.
7 – AS I LAY DYING
AS I LAY DYING is a metal act hailing from San Diego, California, formed in 2000. Initially formed by members Tim Lambesis (vocals) and Jordan Mancino (drums), AS I LAY DYING smashed their way to prominence within the Metalcore scene with their aggressive sound.
Within the genre, AS I LAY DYING occupies a prominent position, known for their blistering combination of melodic hooks, ferocious breakdowns, and technical prowess. Their music often features a blend of melodic guitar lines juxtaposed with crushing rhythms, creating a dynamic and energetic sonic landscape.
Lyrically, AS I LAY DYING explores themes of inner turmoil, personal struggle, and redemption, often drawing from vocalist Tim Lambesis‘ own experiences and philosophical reflections. Their introspective and emotionally charged lyrics resonate deeply with their fanbase, contributing to the band’s enduring appeal.
In 2014, Lambesis was convicted for his involvement in a murder-for-hire plot against his estranged wife, resulting in a six-year jail sentence. Following his release in December 2016, Lambesis addressed his crimes and issued a public apology upon AS I LAY DYING‘s reformation in June 2018.
Lambesis remains the band’s sole, original member, however AS I LAY DYING‘s place within Metalcore is solid and defined by their uncompromising sound, heartfelt lyrics, and enduring influence.
6 – ATREYU
ATREYU is a Metalcore band originating from Orange County, California. Formed in 1998, the group’s core lineup would eventually stabilize in 2004 with the addition of bassist Marc McKnight. Joining McKnight was Alex Varkatzas (vocals), Dan Jacobs (guitar), Travis Miguel (guitar) and Brandon Saller (drums, clean vocals), who would go on to be a prominent force in the metal scene for over two decades.
ATREYU occupies a distinctive position, blending elements of aggressive metal with melodic hooks and emotionally charged lyrics. Their music often featured a dynamic interplay between Varkatzas‘ aggressive screams and Saller‘s clean vocals, combined with intricate guitar work and driving rhythms.
As pioneers of the Metalcore movement, ATREYU has exerted a significant influence on the genre. Varkatzas would eventually leave the group in 2021, leading to Saller taking over full vocal duties and musician Kyle Rosa being brought into the fold to sit behind the drum kit.
Throughout their career, ATREYU has released a string of acclaimed albums and toured extensively, building a dedicated fanbase around the world. Their commitment to their music and their fans has remained steadfast, cementing their status as one of the most influential bands in the genre.
5 – PARKWAY DRIVE
PARKWAY DRIVE is an outfit who hail from Byron Bay, New South Wales, Australia, formed in 2003. The band consists of vocalist Winston McCall, guitarists Luke Kilpatrick and Jeff Ling, bassist Jia O’Connor, and drummer Ben Gordon. PARKWAY DRIVE emerged onto the scene with a ferocious energy and a unique blend of melodic hooks, crushing breakdowns, and visceral aggression.
Originating from the remote coastal town of Byron Bay, PARKWAY DRIVE drew inspiration from their surroundings, infusing their music with a raw intensity reflective of their environment. Their early releases, including their debut album “Killing with a Smile” (2005) and sophomore effort “Horizons” (2007), quickly garnered attention for their relentless energy and uncompromising approach to heavy music.
PARKWAY DRIVE are well recognized for their signature blend of brutal breakdowns, intricate guitar work, and McCall‘s distinctive vocals, which seamlessly transition between guttural screams and melodic harmonies. Their music often explores themes of defiance, perseverance, and resilience, resonating deeply with heavy music fans.
PARKWAY DRIVE‘s dedication to their craft and their unwavering commitment to their fanbase has earned them a dedicated following and solidified their status as one of the leading bands in modern Metalcore.
4 – SHADOWS FALL
SHADOWS FALL is a Metalcore band that came together in Springfield, Massachusetts, United States, in 1995. Although SHADOWS FALL has experienced some line-up changes, for most of its recording career, the band has been composed of Jon Donais (lead guitar, backing vocals), Matt Bachand (rhythm guitar, clean vocals), Paul Romanko (bass), Brian Fair (lead vocals), and Jason Bittner (drums). SHADOWS FALL quickly gained recognition within the metal scene for their ferocious blend of thrash, melodic death metal, and hardcore punk influences.
After releasing several independent albums, SHADOWS FALL signed with Century Media Records and released their breakthrough album, “The Art of Balance,” in 2002. The album received critical acclaim and helped establish SHADOWS FALL as one of the leading bands in the New Wave of American Heavy Metal movement.
Throughout their career, SHADOWS FALL continued to release a series of acclaimed albums, including “The War Within” (2004), which earned them a Grammy nomination for Best Metal Performance for the song “What Drives the Weak,” and “Threads of Life” (2007), which debuted at number 46 on the Billboard 200 chart.
SHADOWS FALL‘s place within the Metalcore genre is defined by their intricate guitar work, intense live performances, and diverse range of influences. They have been praised for their technical proficiency, melodic sensibilities, and socially conscious lyrics, which often explore themes of personal struggle, inner turmoil, and societal issues.
Despite undergoing lineup changes over the years, SHADOWS FALL continued to tour and release music until their hiatus in 2014. They would eventually return 6 years later with a promise of new music and sporadic live performances.
3 – BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE
BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE hail from Bridgend, Wales, and came together in 1998. Founded by vocalist and rhythm guitarist Matt Tuck, lead guitarist Michael Paget, drummer Michael Thomas, and bassist Nick Crandle, BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE emerged onto the metal scene with a blend of aggressive riffing, melodic hooks, and emotionally charged lyrics.
BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE gained recognition for their distinctive fusion of metal and melodic elements, characterized by Tuck‘s dynamic vocals and Paget‘s blistering guitar solos. Their music often explores themes of love, loss, and inner turmoil, resonating with fans of both metal and rock.
Overall, BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE‘s place in this list is defined by their melodic intensity, emotive songwriting, and unwavering passion for their music. With a discography spanning multiple acclaimed albums and a reputation for delivering electrifying live performances, BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE continues to be a driving force in the world of Metalcore – despite some lineup changes – and continue to absolutely pummel fans and fellow musicians alike with their powerful blend of aggression and melody.
2 – BRING ME THE HORIZON
Sheffield, England’s BRING ME THE HORIZON emerged in 2004 and remain one of this genre’s most powerful influences, despite their attempt at a departure from Metalcore through continued sonic experimentation.
Featuring vocalist Oliver Sykes, guitarist Lee Malia, bassist Matt Kean and drummer Matt Nicholls. The group would eventually add keyboardist Jordan Fish in 2012 to fill out their ever-growing sound.
BRING ME THE HORIZON initially gained recognition for their blend of crushing breakdowns, melodic hooks, and Sykes‘ distinctive vocal delivery, which ranged from guttural screams to soaring clean vocals. Their early releases, including albums like “Count Your Blessings” (2006) and “Suicide Season” (2008), showcased their ability to seamlessly blend elements of metal with influences from deathcore and electronic music.
Despite a split with Fish in 2023, BRING ME THE HORIZON continues to flourish and influence numerous acts within the genre. They’ve inspired a new generation of bands with their experimental approach to songwriting, incorporating elements of electronic, pop, and even orchestral arrangements into their music. Their impact can be heard in the sound of countless Metalcore and post-hardcore acts, as well as in the broader landscape of modern heavy music.
1 – KILLSWITCH ENGAGE
KILLSWITCH ENGAGE have easily earned their spot at the top of this list, delivering their signature sound in relentless fury for over two decades.
Forming in Westfield, Massachusetts, United States, in 1999, the band was founded by guitarist Adam Dutkiewicz, bassist Mike D’Antonio and guitarist Joel Stroetzel with vocalist Jesse Leach joining shortly after and drummer Justin Foley arriving in 2003.
After releasing their critically acclaimed debut album, “Alive or Just Breathing,” in 2002, Jesse Leach left the band due to personal reasons. He was replaced by Howard Jones, who became the lead vocalist for the band’s next three albums: “The End of Heartache” (2004), “As Daylight Dies” (2006), and “Killswitch Engage” (2009).
However, in 2012, Howard Jones parted ways with KILLSWITCH ENGAGE, citing personal and health issues. Jesse Leach returned to the band as the lead vocalist, reuniting the original lineup.
KILLSWITCH ENGAGE has been a seminal force within the genre, influencing countless bands with their blend of aggressive riffing, melodic hooks, and emotionally charged lyrics.
With a career spanning over two decades and a reputation for delivering electrifying live shows, KILLSWITCH ENGAGE continues to be a driving force in Metalcore, leading a nation of rabid fans clamoring for more.